Note: My apologies. This post failed to clarify all the issues surrounding iodine, thyroid hormone and cancer. Low thyroid function may protect against cancer, so what does that mean for our diets? I’ll be publishing an update as soon as I can get some smart experts to explain all the confusing info out there.
Last week the Environmental Working Group (EWG), a consumer health group, released its handy lists of more than 250 brands of canned foods– -those with and without bisphenol A (BPA), a compound used in plastics and cans that seems to wreak havoc with hormones.
Why wasn’t Eden‘s canned beans on the green list?
To its credit, Eden has been at the forefront of providing clean containers for consumers. Its beans don’t contain BPA or BPS (bisphenol S), a related compound that some companies have started using instead.
Unfortunately, BPS and other substitutes are also turning out to be xenoestrogens, compounds that act like estrogen in the body. Xenoestrogens may be what’s turning male frogs into females and making fish larvae hyperactive. And we women who fill our pores with beauty products and inhale gases in nail salons surely don’t need more xenoestrogens from foods.
So what’s the beef with Eden’s canned beans? Consider three possibilities:
Strike 1: The boycott of Eden foods by people upset with its owner’s anti-abortion stance had nothing to do with EWG’s decision.
Strike 2: Bingo! The problem is Eden’s canned tomato products. EWG’s rules for its go-to list require that all canned goods from the company be BPA-free. Eden’s canned tomato products still contain BPA. (Buy tomato products in glass instead, but don’t lick the lids. BPA is an adhesive, and some companies who use glass packaging have told me there’s still a trace of BPA in their lids.)
Strike 3: Or is it a walk? Eden’s beans are made with kombu, a seaweed rich in iodine; three 1/2 cup servings supplies all our daily iodine needs (150 mcg minimum, according to official nutrient requirements). Just 1/2 teaspoon of iodized salt does that, too.
So do you need more or less iodine in your diet? That may depend.
How’s your thyroid working?
Over the past several years, studies have emerged showing that people with low thyroid function may be less likely to get cancer and better likely to survive it than people with hyperactive or even normal thyroids.
See this review by the Cleveland Clinic’s Dr. Aleck Hercbergs, a radiation oncologist who suggests inducing low thyroid function to treat people with advanced cancer
––and these studies in prostate and breast cancer, both estrogen positive and negative
–and this study of the ovary’s granulosa cells, in which my cancer presented more than two decades ago, when I was 38.
Thyroid hormones promote angiogenesis. That’s the process by which cancer cells grow blood vessels and then spread throughout the body. And iodine in the diet is crucial for producing thyroid hormones.
But iodine’s tricky. Excess iodine as well as deficiency can both be dangerous. So what does that mean for our anti-cancer diets? Stay tuned for next week’s interview with a cancer researcher who can answer that question.
Thanks Harriet! Interesting stuff, as always… especially the stuff about GCT 🙂
hmm.., always interesting and good info, thanks for that;-) However, i have read that seaweed is encouraged, because of the iodine, and w/ the view that breast cancer is discouraged by iodine. I can’t quote the research on that.., but I know i have seen seaweed and iodine supplementation encouraged from more than one source. Are you aware of this view, and if so, can you put it in perspective w/ more info. Thanks for your work. Always find something to go home w/;-))
The cause of cancer is the real issue. According to the National Cancer Institute, a collection of factors play a role in the development of cancer, spread over many overs. Factors include lifestyle, behavioral, and environmental. Lifestyle choices such as diet and physical activity contribute to overall health.
Thanks, Nisha, for your comments. As I’m sure you’re aware, what causes cancer and what causes cancer cells to grow and spread throughout the body are separate issues.